I find myself in an unfamiliar position. My work for the last decade has been focused on helping people shift their perception of conflict from uniformly negative to potentially generative and then practice approaches to address it constructively. Yet here I am, about to share an entire newsletter about why you might decide to avoid or disengage in conflict. Of course, below the surface, these two things are not contradictory – in fact, they are mutually reinforcing. Part of generative conflict is recognizing what conflict has the potential to be generative (or is worth addressing for some other reason); baked into that is also the recognition of what conflict is unlikely to be generative. When we get better at deciding whether to engage in conflict, it usually helps us be more skillful when we are actually addressing conflict head-on.
My inspiration for exploring this topic is the fantastic new book from writer and conflict facilitator, Priya Parker, called, The Art of Fighting: The Transformative Power of Conflict. Parker devotes an entire chapter to this subject and writes, “I deeply believe that not every conflict should be resolved. Not all conflict avoidance is conflict aversion. Some avoidance reflects wisdom, discernment, patience, even humanity.” Drawing from Parker and my own work as a conflict practitioner, here are some of the key questions we might consider when making this critical discernment that Parker references:
Relationship: Who is part of the conflict and what is your relationship with them?
One of the foundational lessons I’ve learned in my life and work is that healthy conflict is a sign of authentic and secure relationships, not a sign of fragile or dysfunctional ones, as many of us may have been taught to believe. Put another way, conflict is an investment in relationships, but it does require time and energy – and not every relationship warrants that investment.
There are relationships we didn’t choose but may be quite important (ie. co-workers, family/in-laws, neighbors). Conversely, among relationships or in groups we’ve chosen to be a part of, we may feel that a limited capacity for engaging in conflict is better spent elsewhere or conserved. This is likely connected to your own facility with conflict: more practice, comfort, and/or ease with conflict will likely mean you have more to devote to various relationships. While I believe we should try to increase this capacity over time, it is useful to be honest about where it stands at any given moment.
Stakes: What are the potential benefits and risks of choosing to engage and what are the potential benefits and risks of choosing not to?
Avoiding conflict is not without benefits. In addition to conserving our conflict capacity, there may be other advantages, especially if the underlying dispute is not that consequential.
Parker also writes: “Sometimes a disagreement isn’t something to bridge. Rather it’s news you can use.” Perhaps identifying a difference or tension gives us the benefit of vital information without much additional benefit from working through it more deeply. Of course, there are risks to avoidance, especially around small but repeated issues that can boil over to an untenable level. We will be well-served by a clear-eyed look at all these pieces.
Another crucial part of assessing the stakes is an analysis of power dynamics. The risks of facing a conflict directly are much higher when you are down-power. At the same time, the benefits may also be greater. Nonetheless, engaging in conflict with someone up-power leaves us far more vulnerable and that should be part of any honest discernment process. If we are up-power in a differential, we should be mindful of the greater risk to our down-power counterparts; consequently, we have greater responsibility to bring up conflict and to be mindful of how increased vulnerability from those down-power to us may shape their own decisions about whether or not to engage.
The Core Issue: Is engaging in this conflict now likely to meaningfully address the root of what’s going on?
Sometimes something else is happening underneath and a conflict is just what has bubbled up to the surface – or what seems more resolvable that what is truly at the heart of the matter. Parker gives one example of this: when a group or organization has reached the natural end of its life, but it feels too painful to admit. As she puts it, “It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking you need a cast when you need a funeral.” Or perhaps what’s at the root is a systems-level issue masquerading as an interpersonal argument.
Another example I’ve witnessed many times is when some kind of individual development or support is necessary, either as a prerequisite for meaningfully engaging in conflict or even sometimes in lieu of it. This can be unprocessed history of trauma or untreated mental health challenges that are blocking one or both participants from a healthy process around conflict. Someone may also need to do their own learning and growth around power-consciousness and their impacts on others, especially in areas like racism, sexism, ableism, or transphobia, before any related conflicts can be productively addressed. And lest you think otherwise, that “someone” might be you.
If you decide not to engage, you might also consider what Parker calls “strategic conflict avoidance” (and I highly recommend you read the book if you’re curious to know more about that). There are different ways to avoid conflict and they are not all created equal. But most critical, I believe, is that we remember with every potential conflict that we do have a choice. It is a choice to engage as much as it is a choice not to. The discernment process will surely be imperfect at times, but reflecting on the questions above can help us wrestle with this essential part of generative conflict.
